7/26/2009

Flowers of Evil


Flowers of Evil is a 7 volume manhwa from Korea. The most important thing to note about this series is that it features twin incest (twincest). So decide right now how much that bothers you before continuing.

Can you stomach it? I'm not asking if you like it, or agree with it, or think it's disgusting. It's central to the story, but that's not all that's there. And I'm talking incest like Angel Sanctuary, not Ouran High School Host Club. Can you push past that and just look at the story as a whole? If your answer is either "Yes, I can put up with it," or "Yes, I enjoy it," then continue reading. If not, then this is not going to be for you, end of story. See you next time.

Now let's get started.
This 7- volume manhwa by Lee Hyeon-Sook is pretty dark and twisted. Twins Se-Joon and Se-Wa are extremely close. For most of her life, Se-Wa has had no one but Se-Joon there for her, he's been her only friend, and he has spoiled and protected her all her life. As a result of their closeness, her preference of shutting herself away from all others, and the naivety that has developed as a result, Se-Wa cannot distinguish between sibling love and romantic love. She doesn't really understand what "love" means, and so she has fallen in love with her brother. Se-Wa thinks this is perfectly natural, but Se-Joon seems to have more mixed feelings. Se-Wa throws herself at him at every given opportunity, crawling into bed with him at night, hanging on him, and becomes exceedingly jealous as an upperclassman tries to date her brother. Se-Joon allows Se-Wa to do these things, but often doesn't instigate them himself, and is even a little embarrassed about it all. Where Se-Wa believe it's innocent and natural, Se-Joon seems to realize it isn't. He tries to push his sister away by dating another girl, and shoving the relationship in Se-Wa's face. This in turn drives Se-Wa toward a new man, a classmate from their old elementary school, Gi-Hoon. A move which doesn't thrill Se-Joon like it should.

The problem is that at the same time Se-Joon tries to push Se-Wa away, he's also doing things to drag her back in again. Even if she wanted to, he makes it near impossible for her to separate herself from him. He messes with her head on purpose, and it's driving her insane. It doesn't help that Gi-Hoon appears to have some secret, ulterior motives for befriending the twins once again (he hasn't seen or talked to them in years), and his true feelings remain unclear for most of the story. It's worth noting that nothing in this manhwa is really as it appears. The story is well-written, if a little confusing at times (the pacing of the few Korean books (and by few, I mean like, 3 or 4) I've read has always felt a little off to me, in terms of pacing and frame staging). It's good at keeping the suspense going, and at keeping you totally fooled up until the very end. It's also very sad, because the relationship between the twins is just so warped and troubling, and you desperately want for them (Se-Wa in particular) to grow and change on their own. So if you don't mind the incest themes (or actual acts of), the story there is touching, heartbreaking, and bittersweet.

The fact that the title for the story comes from Charles Baudelaire's Les Fleurs du mal is not a nonsensical connection. Currently this has no English version, so if you're interested, you're going to have to dig it up online. The art is decent, but I've seen better; though these Korean artists really have a different artistic feel than their Japanese counterparts, which is nice. Good facial expressions for the most part. I should also note, that while this story does contain incest, it's not glorified in any way. These kids live a messed up life, and it doesn't end pretty.

17 comments:

xJAYMANx said...

@Kris-chan: Intriguing! Actually, this reminds me of a couple of other controversial yet striking titles. First, the anime "Koi Kaze". Tastefully, tenderly yet honestly done. Second, the live-action Korean thriller "Old Boy", loosely based on the manga. Choi Min-sik is fantastic in it, which explains why he's one of my fave Asian actors. If "Flowers of Evil" is ever animated, I'd definitely check it out.

Kris said...

Well, it's controversial, but because it's presented the way it is (meaning the relationship between them is totally screwed up, as opposed to being glorified like a doujin or something), it's pretty interesting.

Heh, are you really opposed to reading manga? You always seem to say "I'll just watch the anime." Or do you feel you just don't have the time?

xJAYMANx said...

@Kris-chan: While I didn't read your review line-for-line (to prevent future anime spoilage, lol), I'm guessing that "screwed up" is a matter of perspective too, if it's the only "sane" path that allows them to deal with life, etc. Which is why it's so intriguing, not some glorified crap.

P.S. Yeah, probably. Don't have the time. Or the money$.

xJAYMANx said...

P.S. Besides, it's probably nothing compared to some of the more-extreme live-action Japanese porn I've seen, lol. >_<;

Kris said...

Well, I was referring specifically to the topic of incest.
I actually haven't seen it used a whole lot. Angel Sanctuary obviously (where it's handled a little differently...but then, that whole story is a mess of...messes, lol, but I like it). Ouran High School Host Club plays with it a little bit, but in a joking manner.
So what I meant was "their incestuous relationship is screwed up." Because it's incestuous, lol. Anyway, yeah, that's what makes it intriguing.
And uh, it's crazy mild; there's very little sexual stuff in there, really.

xJAYMANx said...

@Kris-chan: Well, that's what I kinda meant. It might be "screwed up" to us. But to them, from their "screwed up" point-of-view, the "screwed up" incest might be the most logical thing in the world. And if the story is honest, it should present their "logic" that way. It depends on the reader's sensibilities too. Ideally, I should probably "root" for them, not "reject" them. That's what I meant.

Kris said...

You do end up rooting for them, but as individuals, and specifically the female. Not for their relationship together. Which is probably why I liked it.

xJAYMANx said...

@Kris-chan: What about this? If you can find some "Flowers of Evil" scanlations online, maybe I'll add it to my list. Haven't done a "scanlation list" before, so why not?

Kris said...

I did read it online! I will find it again and email the link to you.

xJAYMANx said...

@Kris-chan: Why didn't you say so? This could change everything, lol. Hey, got it, thanx for the link!

But when to start... When to start...

Kris said...

I did say so! You know, if you would actually read my reviews.... :p

This is what I said in the last paragraph:
"Currently this has no English version, so if you're interested, you're going to have to dig it up online. "

xJAYMANx said...

@Kris-chan: Bahhh, that doesn't *explicitly* say you read it online. It's possible you read the Korean hardcopy, lol. Too much thinking and "reading between the lines" to put 2 plus 2 together!

Kris said...

Let it be known that I know only one language, and that is English.

Well, OK, I know a tiny bit of Spanish (whatever I retained from 3 years in HS and 4 semesters in college...which isn't much).

But certainly not any crazy artsy symbol-fied language.

xJAYMANx said...

LOL, fair enough. Noted and catalogued.

Aprilius20 said...

Well, I'm definitely curious as to how you even read it if there's "no English version"- especially since the impression I got from the review was one of someone who knows the story well. Or, on the other hand, was given a free lecture on it by a major fan... I have to admit that I'm not really a fan of manhwa- never did like what I've seen in the papers so far, but the cover for this one seems OK. Interesting story too.

Kris said...

Scanlations, fan translations, online.

Aprilius20 said...

Ah, so what you meant was that there's no 'official' translation. Got it, by bad:3